This looks great. I'm not sure if it covers the odd little suggestion I had sometime ago, that if comments are closed, perhaps it wouldn't show the "reply to comment" line any longer. If that's already been handled and I missed it, cool. I'll be downloading this and using it. If not, please consider this as a friendly reminder.

You write great plugins. Thank you for sharing them.

Now just to add a tiny feature request for when you feel like it.

• A setting for a single level of threading. That is, main comments, and only one sub-level.

Currently, the smallest setting has two levels of threading, as in the screenshot above.

I tried digging through the code, but somehow I failed to see how to solve this.

Hi! Where is the new version?! The only archive I can download is the 1.5 version… :(

Also, it would be better if the plugin used "do_action('comment_form', $post->ID)" (like the standard WordPress comments.php) instead of displaying its own form, in order to maintain compatibility with other plugins.

just wondering if there's a way to get rid of the javascript error alert. The plugin is working just fine, but it comes up whenever you reply to a comment saying something about a div tag. I thought I already commented about this, but it's not here.

Hi!
first, thanks for this wonderful plugin, I love it so much!
Now, I'm having these little problems:
1.- people on Mac's IE 5.0 can't comment or read the comments.
2.- when you click to "cancel the reply" the comment form disapear!

Can you please help me?

Does Threaded Comments work with K2 Beta One 96? If yes, does anything need to be modified or changed?

I'm having an issue with the comment form not remembering author information. It happens to everyone, so I know it's not a cookie/browser issue. What could be going on?

I'm using this plugin and for some reason the "+" and "-" images aren't showing right – any clues?

I'm using WP2b2 and K2r125 BTW.

i need use your plugins but im use WP version 2.** can you write comment.php for wordpress version 2.*** sent me e-mail inzies@gmail.com if you can help me.. please ….

I just wanted to say thanks for creating this plugin and making it available for public use. I love it and how clean and orderly it keeps my comments. I've installed it a couple days ago, and haven't yet upgraded to WP 2.0 because I want to keep using this plugin. I'm sure you're probably working on making a version that'll work with 2.0, so rather than bug you about that, I just wanted to say thank you.

Brian—Hey man, While I really like your plugin's functionality, I'm not really happy with the implementation or the lack of graceful degradation, so I've been working on my own developer-centric threaded comments plugin, and it is near completion.

It won't replace your plugin for many (probably most) users, but might for people who want easier customization and better degradation for users without JS. Basically, if you want a plug-n-play plugin, mine probably won't do, but if you do a bit of hacking in WordPress, mine should be a bit easier to work with. I've followed your naming conventions so that one can move back and forth between the plugins pretty easily.

Anyway, can you give me a shout via email to discuss this a bit? I'd love to start a thread discussing some of the technical details and pros and cons of various approaches to handling complex comment scenarios in WordPress, but I'm not sure that the announcement posts are the place to do it.

Thanks again, for the inspiration and a very useful plugin.

Hi Brian :)

I'm in the process of setting up wordpress to my liking and found the threaded/paged plugin based on this plugin.

A few feature suggestions which I think would be cool (and very useull):
1. Have posts be auto-folded based on certain criterias. The most basic example would be something along the lines of this:

<?php
// Code before The_Loop
$autofold_age = 4 * 7 * 24 * 60 * 60; // 4 weeks (4wks * 7days * 24hrs * 60 mins * 60 secs) = 2419200 seconds
$num_folds = 0;

// Code inside The_Loop
if (strtotime($comment->comment_date) + $autofold_age <= time()) {
if ($num_folds < 0) $js_fold_array .= ',';
$js_fold_array .= $comment->comment_ID;
}

// Code after The_Loop
if (!empty($js_fold_array)) {
?>
<script type="text/javascript">
var foldArray = array(<?php echo $js_fold_array; ?>);
for (var i = 0; i < foldArray.length; i++) {
collapseThread('div-comment-' + foldArray[i]);
}

</script>
<?php
}

?>

Ofcourse this is just an example and won't work just 'out of the box', and I know too little JavaScriptto write that part properly :)

Hope it's something you can use and are able to implement into your plugin :)

Venlig hilsen
Brian igen igen ;)

Insert Gravatar in your plugin, is possible?
Other question:

Why you do not create a specific page for the plugin, thus you show the new realeses in an only place?
Thus you facilitate the spreading.
Tears.